A Dialogue Between Heart and Mind
after Andrew Marvell
HEART
It is all too much. The expectation that we are capable of carrying
all of this. How is it possible for us to not be burdened with more
than we can bear when the cracks have begun to appear with each
new hardship. This world has irrevocably broken me. Tortured me
into paralysis. I no longer feel capable of the catharsis of release.
There is too much grief to let go of. Ya Musawwir, I have been
begging, praying for escape. Can’t You oblige me just this once?
MIND
How your lamenting has caged us both. Must you be so
habitually theatrical? Your inability to feel deserving of
peace is old news. You and I both know better. Enough
wallowing in your selfishly sad sentiments. Enough
speaking in metaphors. We are yearning to put pen to
paper. Enough making me the enemy. You fear the ways
the dunya has hurt you. And you see not how you harm us.
HEART
Don’t I wish I could just do it all logically? How easy to remove the
emotion and depth from it all. Prefrontal cortex driven and rationalize
your way out of this drowning. Synapses snapping neurons into place
at lightning speed to make a quick decision. This everlasting guilt
just transformed into a to-do list. How nice it must be. To accept
that we will never be enough. Of course you must do everything. Of
course you must save everyone. Of course you are comfortable
removing me from the equation. What a good way to avoid the
obligation you have to me, the thing that generously gives you light.
MIND
Listen, beggars can’t be choosers. How can I avoid you
when we are inevitably stuck together? What in this dunya
do you need to run away from? Especially when this dunya
itself is a cage? Can’t you just uncage yourself? Do you
know the privileges you hold to be able to do that? We are
not the Prophet. We do not have a Ghar-e-Hira to escape to.
HEART
Yes it’s true. But perhaps we need one because I desire to be everywhere
and nowhere simultaneously. I desire to not feel bound by the box you put
me in. Ya Khaliq, our creator, makes it all possible. I see no reason to put
limits on what He is capable of. So leave me be. Your fully formed perfect
sentences do not have a place here right now. I will access the catharsis
when I am ready to do so. For now, I would like to lose myself in lament.
MIND
Why must you over-feel our way out of a sound decision.
You agreed with me but ten seconds ago. We may be
infinitely different, but I am confident God assigned us
to this body together for a reason. Ya Rahman may have
unlimited Mercy. But perhaps, let’s not stretch His patience.
HEART
Allah holds us, the hearts, in high importance. Why else are we
mentioned so often in the Qur’an? Why else is our sensitivity
elevated as a strength? I fear that our collaborative nature is at a
crossroads. Me, bound by my sadness. You, bound by your rigidity.
MIND
I fear the same. But I believe this can be solved if we work
together. Do the one thing we are both good at. Just let us
put a pen in our hand. Let us write our way back to each other.
HEART
It appears we finally agree on something.
Bismillah.